1

A friend entered the US 7 years ago on a tourist visa from Europe and has never left. Since then they have maintained employment and paid taxes. They want to return to home country in Europe but don't want to face a 10 year ban. They were thinking that if they entered Mexico or Canada and took a flight to Europe from there then they could avoid the 10 year ban. Does anyone have any experience with this?

In case there is a 10 year ban...

Is there anyway to find a way to return to US as a tourist if they are married to an American citizen who has joined them to live in Europe?

Thanks for everyones insight!

7
  • 2
    If they leave the US by land (thus avoiding the APIS airline report of their departure), DHS will — not knowing they've departed — believe they're still in the US. This is no better and may well be worse than accepting responsibility for the current overstay. Commented Oct 1, 2019 at 22:17
  • 3
    @mcampov I might be missing something here, but surely the point is that the overstayer can’t escape a ban irrespective of how they manage to leave the US without attracting the attention of the authorities? The overstay would still exist and would become a problem if and when they wanted to return.
    – Traveller
    Commented Oct 1, 2019 at 23:08
  • If they are married to a US citizen they have the option to adjust status. It will take a while, but upon successful completion they could travel to Europe.
    – user79729
    Commented Oct 2, 2019 at 2:22
  • 1
    @user79729 I think to do that the US citizen would have to be resident in the US, and the friend would have to stay there until the adjustment goes through. Commented Oct 2, 2019 at 2:55
  • 1
    7 years is not travel but residency — thus this question belongs on Expatriates.
    – gerrit
    Commented Oct 2, 2019 at 8:09

2 Answers 2

7

The 10-year ban is based on the fact of their accrual of more than 1 year of "unlawful presence" and then departing the US. Even if the government does not know when they left the US, the ban still exists after they leave the US, as a matter of law, even if the government might not be aware of it yet. Leaving the US by land might very well mean that the government is not informed of their departure, but that does not "avoid the ban".

When they next applies for a visa or ESTA, they will be asked about his past stays in the US and whether they have overstayed, so they must disclose their overstay. If they lie, that is fraud and a much more serious violation. If the officer sees that they did not have a departure record the last time, the burden of proof will be on your friend to prove that he left when he says he left.

If they wish to enter the US during the duration of the ban, they would need to apply for a waiver. If they wish to visit as a nonimmigrant, and their visa is denied due solely to the ban and not due to immigrant intent, they can apply for a nonimmigrant waiver. However, they are almost certainly going to be denied also for immigrant intent due to the long overstay, and there is no waiver for that.

If they wish to immigrate, they would need an immigrant waiver, and an immigrant waiver for this ban is only possible if they can show that their US citizen or permanent resident spouse or parent would suffer "extreme hardship" if they can't be in the US, and that is extremely hard to prove, especially if the US citizen spouse has joined them in Europe, so isn't separated from them.

If they are married to, or will be married to, a US citizen, why not just get a green card within the US via Adjustment of Status? As long as they haven't left the US, they can do Adjustment of Status as the spouse of a US citizen without any waivers, regardless of how many years they have overstayed. Or do you mean that they don't want to stay in the US?

2

Another good reason to apply for a Adjustment of Status (meantioned in the previous answer), is that they are, for the Internal Revenue Service, in one form or another a Foreign Persons

Since they are married to a US-Citizen spouse, who must continue to file tax returns in Europe which must include information about the spouse, the IRS will know that they have left. As long as their Departing Alien Clearance is in order then they are fine, but if not ....

Applying for the Adjustment of Status may be a better option.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .