24

It seems that neither New York in general nor Manhattan have any kind of residential parking system as of 2016. Does this mean that a tourist can just go and park a car in Manhattan free of charge?

I am aware that driving in central NYC is a bad idea but it's always nice to get free parking if possible.

  • 20
    If you can find a parking space without a meter.... – Roddy of the Frozen Peas Dec 27 '16 at 10:44
  • 12
    Locals pay the meters when the meters are in force. Some meters in Manhattan at least are only for commercial vehicles, though, so do be careful and read the signs. But the basic principle is that there is no difference in parking enforcement based on the car's state of registration, and there's no way to know whether a New York car is from NYC or elsewhere. This is one of the main reasons why most Manhattanites don't have cars. – phoog Dec 27 '16 at 13:19
  • 5
    Anecdotally: Years ago I as a stupid tourist thought I'd read the signs correctly and found a legal park spot on the street in Manhattan. Wasn't impressed when I got back to find the car had been impounded within a few short hours. Just.... don't. – yochannah Dec 27 '16 at 23:07
  • 3
    Park in Queens and take the subway. – axsvl77 Dec 28 '16 at 16:41
  • 5
    You could make this question shorter by asking if a tourist in NYC can buy a winning lotto ticket. – HopelessN00b Dec 29 '16 at 3:25
34

Yes. Any tourist can park in the same areas as a resident. The only "benefit" for residents of NYC is an exemption from paying the NYC 8% parking tax, though they still pay NY State portion of the tax of 10.375%.

In many areas of the city, largely south of E52nd street, almost all street parking is prohibited with exceptions made for Commercial vehicles (NY state license plate reads "commercial") and Handicap/Disabled parking.

Many parking garages offer coupons by visiting their site first, then downloading to your phone or printing. Icon Parking, Quik Park and LAZ Parking seem to own most garages. Sites like ParkWhiz can locate cheap parking for you, and often offer deals by directing traffic to specific garages.

All parking garages by law must post the rate clearly. It won't include the 18% sales tax. Be sure to know your car size, as they will charge extra for long, wide, tall, oversize, lifted, big tires, SUVs, etc.
Also, the rates are largely by-the-hour. Rates are lowest for people who arrive early (usually 7am - 10am) and stay over 8 hours and less than 12 hours. In that case, it will usually be a flat fee. I pay $27.00 (includes tax) to park in Midtown (busy area) from 7:00am - 6:45pm.

Some helpful notes, if you're serious about street parking:

  • Look closely where a fire hydrant is located. You may not park within 15 feet of either side. You will be ticketed. The distance will not be marked.
  • You may not park at the end of any street with either end of your car protruding into a crosswalk, unless the crosswalk is specifically not painted in the parking area as to allow room for a car. This is rare.
  • Do not park too far away from the curb. You will get a ticket. Usually a 8" to 1ft max. Do not park with your tires on and touching the curb, you will be ticketed.
  • It is possible to get a parking spot on the street. These can be found by waiting on a street until the street sweeper passes. As soon as they pass, drive into a spot behind the street sweeper and park. Do not leave your car, as you will still get a ticket. You must wait until the parking restriction time has elapsed, even though the street sweeper has already come. There can be fights that erupt, as residents wait in their cars idling on one side of the street and rush to the other side.
  • NYC DOT (Dept of Transportation) map with parking restrictions. Includes Alternative Side Parking (ASP) rules. Click "Parking Signs" as a map layer.
  • ASP schedule is tweeted daily at 7:30am and 4:30pm ET by Twitter account "NYCASP".
  • The ASP calendar for 2016, 2017 and temporary suspensions.
  • Manhattan residents are exempt from paying the additional New York City 8% Parking Tax. Manhattan residents instead pay only the tax on parking services at a rate of 10.375% instead of 18.375% that is imposed under State law.
  • 3
    @JonathanReez it's an additional 8% on the sales tax a parking tower charges you. – Mark Henderson Dec 27 '16 at 23:53
  • 3
    Getting a spot on the street does not literally require following the street sweeper. I grew up in Manhattan, and never once did that. Street parking is a pain, but it’s entirely do-able in many areas of the city (and entirely impossible in others, particularly touristy sections, but I digress). – KRyan Dec 28 '16 at 2:26
  • 5
    For 27 USD I can rent a private single garage in most German cities for a month. – simbabque Dec 28 '16 at 15:46
  • 4
    @simbabque failing to see how that is in any way relevant? – Mark Henderson Dec 28 '16 at 16:05
  • 3
    @simbabque yes, it is high (sometimes way higher) even if you compare to most, if not all cities in the US. But we are talking about NYC here. See this for a comparison – Nivas Dec 28 '16 at 17:27
32

In Theory... sure.

In practice...

Unless you have a fairly good understanding of New York's somewhat arcane Alternate Side Parking rules, the patience of a saint, and the willingness to walk all the way across town once you've found a spot - and then to move your car daily and do it all again because of the aforementioned ASP rules - you're not going to find this viable or pleasant.

  • 5
    It should also be noted that at certain times of year (summer weekends, thanksgiving weekend, winter holidays) many New Yorkers who have cars use them to leave the city, making it easier to find a spot, and street-cleaning rules are suspended, reducing the need to move the car around. – phoog Dec 27 '16 at 13:25
  • 5
    Sure. But ASP suspensions aren't quite as predictable or consistent as a blanket "holiday == free parking". That's where the 'fairly good understanding' part I mention comes in. The point is, it's not worth planning on unless you already know how the system works. – LessPop_MoreFizz Dec 27 '16 at 13:28
  • 13
    Can we convince you to teach us about this system? Sounds mighty interesting. – Mast Dec 27 '16 at 18:01
  • 8
    @Mast it's not. The system is "most of the time, you have to do what the sign says. On most holidays, and occasionally for emergencies and special events, you don't." TV and radio news make a point of saying "alternate side parking rules are suspended" on days when they are, and the info is also published on the web and twitter. It's not so much arcane as inconvenient, because Murphy's law dictates that you'll have to move your car at the least convenient possible time. – hobbs Dec 28 '16 at 5:00
  • 4
1

Another helpful tip, is look for spots in neighborhoods near your destination where street parking is usually more available, then you can hop on a nearby subway line to get to your destination. For example, if you want to go somewhere off the 2/3 or A/C or 4/5 or J/Z line, there is usually free parking between the South Street Seaport and the Brooklyn Bridge - and these spots are a short walk from all these subway lines at the Fulton Street Center (Fulton St. & Broadway). As stated above, just make sure you are not violating the alternate side parking rules on nearby signs, and that you are not blocking fire hydrants or driveways.

A couple other examples: on Riverside Drive from about 72nd Street on the Upper West Side all the way up to Washington Heights - this is a short walk to many 1 and 2/3 train stations. Bonus: there are hardly any driveways.

0

I would like to point out that NYC, Washington D.C. and other "large" meto areas in the New England area are generally considered "public transit friendly."

For example, last time I stayed in D.C. I parked my car at the hotel upon arival, and took combinations of the Subway, Train, Taxi, and Bus anywhere I wanted to go. I didn't drive at all that week.

IIRC NYC and srounding areas are very similar. You typically walk, or take public transit everywhere.

Your hotel should offer you some parking options, though, if your flying in, best to not even get a rental. Just take a taxi instead.

  • While your point is well taken, neither NYC nor D.C. is in "New England" by a long shot. – LessPop_MoreFizz Dec 31 '16 at 15:35
  • Didn't mean that they were, just that the same goes for them. – coteyr Dec 31 '16 at 19:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.