Travel Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for road warriors and seasoned travelers. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
I'm going to take the Zürich-Hamburg ICE train using my Interrail pass, and know that seat reservation is optional on this Train.
As I've never Interrailed before, I wonder: what would happen in case all places are sold out on a train where reservation is not compulsory?
Would I get kicked off the train, or simply have to stand? The second scenario is perfectly fine with me; the first one is not because I have a set itinerary
First, it is very, very unlikely for German ICEs to have all seats reserved. Many Germans don’t reserve their seats because they either have season tickets or a non-fixed itinerary or don’t want to pay the reservation fee. (This may change once reservations are included in the ticket price, but that has recently been postponed to a later, unannounced date.)
However, it still happens that a train is full of people despite not being fully reserved. Often, this is because a double unit of one of the later ICE builds (not the first generation; they are a single train not designed for doubling or splitting) is reduced to a single unit (typically due to technical problems). In much rarer cases this is due to a demand higher than what can be accomodated (Hamburg–Copenhagen was one before they introduced compulsory reservation a few years ago). If this happens, there is a number of things that can happen:
The train still leaves because the staff decides it is safe.
This will typically be the case if there are people standing in the corridors, but it is not fully packed and people can still walk back and forth.
The train won’t leave because staff decides it is no longer considered safe.
People are then asked to leave nicely, then less nicely. (Contrary to the other answer, I have never heard of the offer of vouchers to voluntarily leaving.)
The police is called and forcefully removes random people from the train.
Once enough people have removed themselves/have been removed, the train leaves with often considerable delay.
To reduce your odds of falling victim to the second bullet point, it is helpful to be among the first to board a train, even if that involves an odd bit of pushing and shoving (seen as highly unfriendly, of course; don’t overdo it!). Typically, those closest to the exits will be removed if the police are called.
Also, when grabbing any empty seat, make note whether the little electronic sign above it notes two stations between which the seat is reserved. Occasionally, it says ggf. freigeben instead, because somebody booked the reservation only shortly before departure,[1] or it says bahn.comfort for a special contingent of seats offered to the frequent travellers who acquired comfort status. If your seat says neither, it is extremely unlikely that you are removed from the train. The police does not check tickets to remove any passanger preferentially.
Finally, the Zürich–Hamburg train is one that is not too likely to be full — however, the peak travel times are Friday afternoons and Sundays. During those days you may have a harder time finding a seat. I haven’t had a train of that particular relation being too full to leave yet, though; and it is typically served by the oldest ICE generation.
Notes:
[1]: I used to think that ggf. freigeben could also mean the train’s IT failed. Turns out that in that case the signs would read GGF. FREIGEBEN in capital letters, making it easy to distinguish the two. When I saw the all caps version (displayed on every seat, so obviously erroneous), I attributed it to a different ICE build than what I normally travel with.
You would have to stand, unless there are too many people standing, so that escape ways would be blocked. In that case at first they would ask for volunteers to vacate the train (they might get some vouchers etc.). If that doesn't work out, then the police will come and remove some passengers (without getting vouchers). The last case happened some times in the last years, but it's not very regular. The first case happened to me once, and I got a 25 Euro voucher, and just took the next train, which left 30 minutes later.
If you are travelling terminus to terminus on a ICE train it is unlikely that you will not be able to find a seat, especially if you are not travelling at peak business times. I have used ICE trains before without reserving and never struggled to find a seat. Just check the small display above the seat and be prepared to move if a seat is free now but not later; for example the seat my be free from Hamburg to Basel but booked there after.
I did take a look on one of the popular English language forums for Germany just to check though, and it looks like you are able to stand, should you find there are no seats available.
Just book a seat reservation only, without a ticket, if you are worried. Pick a train, select book without registering to pay with paypal or credit card, and print your reservation
This question is still relevant today, specifically for the Zurich-Hamburg route. Also valid for any ICE train out of Basel going up to Frankfurt and further north, including those starting at Interlaken Ost through Bern.
During Easter holiday season, the second class can be full. I saw the cars full of kids and teens from school groups and holiday camps. Between Karlsruhe and Mannheim, I had to sit on the doorsteps, as I forgot to reserve, and that "ggf.freigeben" was seen everywhere.
If you need to travel during this time, book your seat. Or, if you can afford it, get the 1st class Interrail pass. When the second class is full, you can still find some free seats in the first class.
First class Interrail passes cost 25% more than their second class counterparts. This is a bargain, knowing that the price difference between a 2nd class and 1st class regular tickets can be much higher, depending on the country. For example, in Switzerland, the full price 1st class is a 75% price hike over the second class, except discounted offers.
