7

On my recent trip when I returned back to the airport, I was forced to open the baggage at customs. It is my bad that I said to the police there (are they police?) that this is my first trip and thus I don't know what to do. He kindly taught me what I should do, and instructed me to open the baggage, which he checked out.

However, I asked him why some people are forced to open the baggage while others can just pass through it. He said it is just random and not based on whether he suspects the passenger or not.

That being said, as far as I watch it, all people that were forced to open the baggage are men! Sigh. If they just check it at random this would never happen, especially because there are certainly more women than men.

This led me to wonder how they decide to claim to open the baggage. Surely I don't like to be getting into such trouble. Are there any ways, tips, or tactics to avoid being suspected there? Or are there any characteristics that make people more likely to be suspected (other than being men which I think is gender discrimination)?

  • 3
    @JonathanReez - I am white and TSA-Pre and a high level elite flyer AND have been "selected" for bag searches flying back from Asia. Anyone can be selected at random, there is no way to totally avoid it. I don't even think having Global Entry helps you when it comes to random custom searches. – user13044 Jun 4 '16 at 6:35
  • 2
    They could have x-rayed incoming baggage and then decided to question anyone who might have particular items in baggage. I'm a ham radio operator and every time I'm coming back to my home airport with my radio, this triggers a "random" customs inspection. – AndrejaKo Jun 4 '16 at 12:58
  • 18
    if it were possible to ensure you wouldn't be searched, smugglers would do whatever it is that prevents searches. It's not possible. Relax, it doesn't take long, and it doesn't mean you're in trouble. – Kate Gregory Jun 5 '16 at 19:47
  • I have a colleague, a law-abiding German citizen of unimpeachable reputation... for some reason he wears long hair and a mustache and looks like the bad Mexican bandit in Clint Eastwood movies. He gets stopped and searched everywhere he goes; his suitcases, his car, his briefcase, his bodily cavities. We reckon he enjoys it. – RedSonja Sep 30 '16 at 13:03
  • A man here who has travelled a lot in Europe, Asia, and North America for several decades. I have only been asked to open my bags once. So, I don't think that they pick on men. My wife has been asked at least once, maybe more. – badjohn Aug 14 '17 at 19:19
22

Customs officers generally have the legal authority (the details will be different depending on the country) to search all articles, and typically people, entering or leaving their country. As a matter of efficiency, it makes the most sense for them to focus their efforts on passengers they believe may be carrying prohibited items. Every country's customs service works a little differently, and will have different priorities for what they're looking for and how fast they need to move travelers through the line, but here's a non-exhaustive list of the kinds of criteria they may employ:

  • Random searches. This may be part of an organized agency effort to statistically determine compliance rates by following a rigorous randomization procedure (e.g. every 50th person to walk past this point receives this type of search, allowing officers to estimate how many unsearched people are carrying prohibited items and going undetected) or a more ad-hoc effort.
  • Profiling. Customs officers are looking for people who "look suspicious" based on their training and experience as to passengers who most often bring prohibited items. The exact nature of the profiling, especially around race and ethnicity, may depend on national laws and agency policies, and the particular biases and practices of individual officers. Some forms of discrimination may sometimes be legal at the border even where national laws would ordinarily prohibit it in other contexts.
  • Your appearance and demeanor. Do you appear nervous or trying to hide something? Are you sweating? (I've even been specifically asked why I was sweating by an immigration officer once.) How are you dressed? What kind of shoes are you wearing?
  • Where you're coming from and how long you were there
  • Your luggage: type, quantity, weight, cost, appearance, etc...
  • Information in government databases about you, including a past history with Customs or law enforcement, intelligence, a tip-off from someone that you were acting suspiciously, your travel history, etc... Some governments receive the entire PNR for your travel, and may apply secret risk assessment algorithms to select passengers of interest for a search.
  • Trained dogs reacting to your person or bags
  • Your answers to any questions, either orally or on a declaration card.
  • Some countries may examine or X-ray bags before they even arrive at the baggage claim, identify ones of interest, and have officers watch to see who picks them up before performing a search.
  • While a bag search is often a customs matter, officers may look at bags as part of the immigration process as well (or immigration and customs may be combined functions), especially if they are unsure whether to allow you in the country. They may be looking for anything that appears inconsistent with your stated reasons for travel, say bringing work tools and equipment on a vacation or copies of your resume and diplomas when you're visiting on a tourist visa.

The US CBP also has a not terribly helpful article: Reasons CBP Officers search passengers.

These factors can work together. A nervous-looking young man traveling alone who visited Colombia for just 24 hours, said he was there on vacation, and is carrying five large brand-new suitcases is going to raise a whole host of red flags.

There isn't a lot you can really do to avoid such a search, and I'd caution that most efforts to artificially change your demeanor will probably wind up making you appear more suspicious, as "nervous person trying way too hard not to look nervous" is not a good look. It is possible that you triggered some suspicion in an officer's eye; it is possible that the search really was truly random; and it is possible that they were singling out men for some reason or no reason at all. Mainly, you can avoid being searched by looking and acting like a typical traveler, and accept that sometimes your bags may be searched for no particular reason.

You may consider watching some of the TV programs that have been produced about Immigration and Customs officers (Homeland Security USA, Border Security: Australia's Front Line, UK Border Force, etc...) for a sanitized, government-friendly view of what these officers are looking for and how their jobs generally work.

All that said, most customs authorities do have a complaints procedure that you may use if you believe you have been treated unfairly or that illegal discrimination was used against you.

  • 1
    And in rare cases that I have actually seen happening, they will search almost an entire plane, especially if the departure country has a reputation for something or another. – Jan Jun 4 '16 at 12:53
  • Of course “every 50th person to walk past this point” is not random, and such a system is open to being subverted by people wanting to avoid being searched, so isn’t going to be used in practice. – rhialto Dec 28 '18 at 0:48
  • @rhialto I'm aware of at least one airport that used to use "first person past this point at x:00 and x:30, every hour". Which yes, because it can be observed (and reproduced!) won't produce a representative sample. – gsnedders Jun 4 at 19:44

protected by Community Jun 5 at 12:38

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.