2

In the movie Edge of Tomorrow, the main characters were travelling by road from Normandy in France to somewhere in the mountains of Germany (a dam)1. During the journey, one of the characters mentions passing through Lyon, France. Google Maps shows it thus:

  1. We decided in comments to narrow it down to "Sylvenstein (dam), about 1 hour south of Munich in the Bavarian Alps"

map

The highlight (red marker) is on the Bavarian Alps (not the only mountains in Germany to be sure, but some of the most southern). The two stars joined by a red line represent Normandy in the north-west and Lyon in the south-east.

But.. That is heading south east, towards Italy or Switzerland, as opposed to due east, to reach Germany (their supposed destination).

The characters wanted to avoid Paris (it turns out it was heavily defended by 'the enemy' - but would probably have been expected by the characters to be unsafe to pass through even without that specific knowledge).

So, if you're at Normandy, and wish to reach the mountains (anywhere) in Germany but avoiding Paris, would the logical path take you through Lyon (..then presumably Switzerland)?

closed as primarily opinion-based by Maître Peseur, CGCampbell, Mark Mayo, jwenting, VMAtm May 25 '15 at 11:59

Many good questions generate some degree of opinion based on expert experience, but answers to this question will tend to be almost entirely based on opinions, rather than facts, references, or specific expertise. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 1
    "...Omega hiding within a Bavarian Alps dam..." from en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edge_of_Tomorrow_%28film%29 your dot would be about 120 km east of where you placed it, but that's fine, close enough – Gayot Fow May 22 '15 at 17:45
  • 1
  • 4
    In general, the problem is not so much the length of the route, but more where the road network is. In that case, France is very centralized around Paris, it means all networks (road, train, planes) go through Paris. Not literally because Paris area is big, but within 100km of Paris, probably. Then it is possible to go through Lyon (even though Dijon seems a better choice), as you can see the road network on the map. Swiss infrastructure is probably good and fast, so it sounds likely possible to follow that route. – Vince May 22 '15 at 18:22
  • @Vince Then it is possible to go through Lyon (even though Dijon seems a better choice) I was thinking that as I perused the map. Even if they were forced to skirt south of Paris, the route seemed shorter by heading back north a little & through Dijon rather than continuing all the way to Lyon. Though that might not be the case for the most eastern alps within Germany. "Swiss infrastructure is probably good and fast" I had heard that. Perhaps it was a factor in continuing to Lyon before heading to Geneva, then through Switzerland further east and north into Germany.. – Andrew Thompson May 22 '15 at 18:32
  • 1
    @GayotFow "That would seem to narrow it down to Sylvenstein, about 1 hour south of Munich in the Bavarian Alps." Let's pin it down as that. "But of course the entire location could be fictional." The film makers were (I think) careful to go with 'plausible' locations for each part of the action, so I think that is as good a destination as any.. – Andrew Thompson May 22 '15 at 18:43
4

Broadly, the answer to your question is 'no', there is no logic that routes the traveller through Lyon. Assuming that the two end points are Omaha Beach in Normandy and the Sylvenstein Dam in the Bavarian Alps, the prima facie route is Caen - Paris - Stuttgart - Munich. It's shown below...

enter image description here

Even in the fictional journey from Normandy to the Bavarian Alps, there is no reason to avoid Paris without bestowing prescience on the hero, and if the hero were prescient he wouldn't have gone to Germany in the first instance. Moreover, the scriptwriters could have placed the helicopter in any location, Strasbourg for example.

enter image description here

Given that Lyon is a ridiculously off-the-wall route, your question (which is borderline topical by the way) raises an interesting on-topic question...

Is there anything about Lyon that would prompt a film director to pay homage to it? Even if it were an homage understood by insiders only?

Yes. Lyon is a city that has provided the location for a many great films. The city also has an impressive list of notable residents. Any of these might provide the grounding for an homage or tribute.

Beyond this (or some similar outré reason), there is no "logical path" between Normandy and Sylvenstein that situates Lyon as a way-point.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.