5

I have read that only Muslims can visit Mecca and that foreigners need to apply for the Hajj visa and provide a receipt from a local Muslim center. Are Saudi citizens who are Christian able to visit Mecca without such requirements?

I am specifically interested in Saudi Arabian citizens, not tourists. Sorry if this question is out of place, apparently the mods at Politics SE are too stringent to allow this sort of inquiry.

3

1 Answer 1

18

Exactly as others have pointed out, citizens of Saudi Arabia, whether born or naturalized, must be Muslims. Period. They are all viewed as Muslims by the law and authorities, and they must behave like Muslims (i.e. they must observe Sunni Islam), and as such they are free to visit Mecca and other holy sites of Islam in Saudi Arabia. If they want to convert to another religion or become atheists, they must emigrate (and possibly keep hiding from their families), otherwise they are going to face harsh penalties, such as flogging, prison time, or even death.

Of course, not all Saudi citizens are devout Muslims, but secretly not observing Islam, in case of citizens, is only possible to a very small extent in Saudi Arabia. Religious police checks that everyone participates at Friday prayers, observes the Ramadan, abstains from alcohol, etc. Non-Muslim foreigners are allowed not to observe Islam, but some things are only allowed in their gated compounds (e.g. daytime eating during Ramadan) and some things are officially banned even for them (e.g. extramarital or homosexual sex).

Naturalized citizens must declare their islamic faith before obtaining citizenship (not that it happens too often). From that moment on, they are viewed as Muslims and must adhere to the same rules as natives.

Saudi Arabia is by far the stricktest islamic country in the world. Many other Muslim-majority countries are more tolerant and many have indigenous religious minorities (incl. Christians), but apostasy (stopping being a Muslim if you previously were one) is a crime in most (if not all) of them.

4
  • 3
    Post-2016, much of this is no longer true. The power of the religious police has been much reduced and they never "checked that everyone participates in the Friday prayers", only that people aren't obviously violating the rules. These days eg Afghanistan is much, much stricter. Commented Sep 4 at 11:48
  • @lambshaanxy both are equally strict, it's the openness of the violence against "heretics" that's more blatant in Afghanistan. Where in SA you're shot or beheaded in a closed prison yard, in Afghanistan you're hung or stoned in public.
    – jwenting
    Commented Sep 4 at 12:35
  • 4
    @lambshaanxy Quite the contrary, even though the power of the religious police has been reduced, much of this still applies. AFAIK, if you're seen in the streets doing nothing during Friday prayers, the police will usher you to the nearest mosque. True, if you're at home, they won't drag you out. Commented Sep 4 at 12:39
  • 7
    Can you provide references or other supporting evidence for these statements? Commented Sep 4 at 14:22

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .