3

I would like to compare two airports in terms of how cheap/expensive it is to fly from these two airports to a specific set of airports I frequently fly to. Is there any convenient way to do so?


Example:

  • two departure airports = {SFO, SEA}
  • set of airports I frequently fly to = {CDG, HKG, ICN, MNL, PVG, TPE, SIN}

Which departure airport is typically cheaper, and what's the price difference?

Motivation: I am comparing the cost of living between different cities, and I include the airport affordability as part of the cost of living.


What I found so far:

6
  • I'm not sure I understand the question. If you live reasonably close to both airports, why don't you just pick the cheaper one for each specific trip? Why would it matter which one is cheaper "on average"? – Hilmar Dec 27 '20 at 21:31
  • @Hilmar I am comparing the cost of living between different cities, and I include the airport affordability as part of the cost of living. – Franck Dernoncourt Dec 27 '20 at 21:34
  • I'm not sure I really understand the question either, but Google Flights allows you to select multiple destinations and multiple origins – Midavalo Dec 27 '20 at 21:49
  • @Midavalo thank you I added a complete example. Is it clear now? If we give multiple destinations and multiple origins in Google Flights, then it isn't clear which departure airport is typically cheaper on average. – Franck Dernoncourt Dec 27 '20 at 21:54
  • 1
    @Midavalo I read the question as the OP is considering moving to somewhere near either SFO or SEA and wishes to factor in the difference in ticket price to a set of known destinations into the overall cost of living at each departure location. EG to figure if SEA has cheaper accommodation, do the relative flight costs makes it cheaper or more expensive overall than living near SFO. (And I have no idea if living near SEA is actually cheaper than near to SFO - thats for illustration purposes only) – Peter M Dec 27 '20 at 22:25
7

How can I easily compare the affordability of two departure airports ...

By looking at prices on Google Flights for durations, dates & booking classes that are representative of your specific flight plans, populating a spreadsheet, and looking at the results.

Sorry, I'm not trying to be snarky here. Google Flight's "price on calendar feature" and specifically the prize graphs are great tools to effectively display a large set of flight prices and quickly distill it to a single number. I just looked up SFO/SEA to TPE/HKG/MNL for Jan + Feb, and it took me less than two minutes, a lot less than writing this answer :-)

If you want to get really fancy and find the absolute lowest price for both airports at the same time, you can use ITA Matrix instead, but it'll take a you a few minutes longer.

FWIW: I didn't see any meaningful difference in my quick research. Differences seemed less than 10% and just "noise".

There is more than just price to pick a "preferred" airport.

  1. SFO serves way more international destinations than SEA, including all of your targets (SEA currently doesn't serve HKG or MNL) so it's better for non-stop.
  2. SFO is a hub for United, which serves all of your destinations. So if you fly a lot (or some premium cabin) you would be much more likely to accumulate benefits and status. While the airlines have devalued their loyalty programs a lot in recent years, it can still be fairly valuable in the right circumstances. SEA's only hub airlines is Alaska, which is North America only (plus Costa Rica).
  3. Getting to/from the airport: That will depend a lot on where you live relative to the airport and/or public transit, but it's often a non-trivial part of the overall trip cost.

Needless to say: housing is substantially more expensive in the Bay Area, so unless you fly a whole lot AND pay everything out of your pocket (and not on company/business dime), the difference in actual ticket prices will not make a meaningful difference and it feels like the tail wagging the dog.

3

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.