2

So, my sister lives in Canada and she travelled to US and change some of her currencies to US currencies(about $100 US). A week later, she went back to Canada and tried to change her US currencies back to Canadian ones. The equivalence of US currencies went down and she lost about ($10 Canadian). I'm wondering if this happened to anyone and lost a lot of money? What did you do?

closed as off-topic by David Richerby, Glorfindel, bytebuster, user90371, Ali Awan Jul 4 at 4:43

  • This question does not appear to be about traveling within the scope defined in the help center.
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 2
    On the other hand people also make (lots of) money with foreign currency exchanges ... (See for instance en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_exchange_market) Although the service charges banks and similar can charge (especially for handling cash) make losing money on currency much more likely for a consumer. – HBruijn Jul 3 at 13:27
  • 8
    The CAD/USD exchange rate does not generally fluctuate so rapidly that one would lose 10% in a week. Almost all (or possibly even 100%) of her losses were due to transaction fees or rate spread (spread is the difference between the rate to buy CAD with USD and the rate to buy USD with CAD), or possibly the difference between the rates in the US vs. the rates in Canada (in my experience you get a better rate in the country whose currency you're buying). You can minimize these losses by shopping around, but you cannot eliminate them. – phoog Jul 3 at 13:29
  • 5
    I'm voting to close this question as off-topic because it is a survey, not an objectively answerable question. – David Richerby Jul 3 at 14:14
  • 1
    This is almost the same situation as "I bought a company's stock, but when I sold it, the price had gone down and I lost money. What should I do?" Especially when you add transaction fees, as @phoog said in his comment. – Mike Harris Jul 3 at 14:46
14

This happens. There is not much to do about it once the loss has occurred. It's just a risk that's inherent in exchanging money.

(Most of your sister's loss must have been in fees or buy/sell spread rather than exchange rate moves, because the USD/CAD rate has not moved as much as 10% during the last year).

You can try to minimize your exposure to exchange-rate losses by

  • not exchanging more money that you think you'll need to spend.

  • pay with a credit or debit card when abroad. The card issuer will exchange only the amount you actually spend.

  • if you're often going to the same country, consider keeping your stash of emergency cash from trip to trip instead of changing it back to your own currency when you get home.

  • bring emergency cash in your own currency and exchange it locally only if an emergency that you need to cover arises. Exchanging the money abroad may be more expensive than at home, but in most cases you won't need to (because no emergency).

5

This happens to everyone everywhere when exchanging currencies.

  1. The exchange rates between currencies varies everyday due to many factors. You can "gamble" by exchanging your money when you feel it is advantageous to you (when the rates are high).
  2. Banks (and exchange offices) will buy and sell currencies are different rates. For example, my Canadian bank will buy US dollars at 1,2744 and sell at 1,3451.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.