2

I am planning to bring my mother in visitor visa to Germany for a couple of months. At the moment she is staying with my wife in Sri Lanka. Later I planned to file a hardship case and see if I can prove that she is dependent on me to try to bring her for a long stay. Because my wife will soon join me here and mom will be alone when that happens. She is 61 and widowed. She also doesn't speak the majority language in my country and is dependent on me for a living and she is emotionally dependent on me. So it'd be really helpful for her if I can bring her on a long stay.

closed as off-topic by Neusser, Giorgio, user 56513, Michael Hampton, gmauch Oct 23 '18 at 21:33

This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:

If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • How does this differ from your other question? – user79658 Oct 23 '18 at 11:58
  • Possible duplicate of Getting mom sponsored through her brother for Schengen – user79658 Oct 23 '18 at 11:59
  • That question is to understand whether she will make it through her brother's sponsorship to Germany. This question is to know whether it will be problematical to bring her on a long term visa, if I myself sponsor her on a short term visa. Hope the difference is clear. Please remove the duplicate tag as these two questions are not related at all. – mayooran Oct 23 '18 at 12:05
3

It is always hard to predict how authorities will act, but I cannot see any good reason why it would make it harder for your mother to get a permit to stay with your wife any yourself in Germany if she had been visiting Germany once before.

I am sure you have already found the relevant information on the website of the Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge, aka BAMF, the German agency dealing with immigration?

The basic information at http://www.bamf.de/EN/Migration/EhepartnerFamilie/ehepartnerfamilie-node.html says:

What they basically say is:

  • You as the "head of family" who wants to reunite with his family members in Germany need to be able to sustain yourself financially and provide your familiy with money to live and with housing.
  • Famility members who come to Germany need to have some basic knowledge of the German language, but there are exceptions to that rule.

So assuming you are in Germany on a legal base, have a permanent right to stay and work in Germany and you have a reasonable income, chances are you will succeed in getting your wife and your mother here.

Just one word of caution: It way take time. But back to your original question, there is really no reason why your mother visiting upfront would cause any issue.

  • Thanks a lot for the hopeful words Torsten. My wife will not be needing German since I have a blue card. But I asked her to do A1 and come anyway. Hopefully the long term stay would work out with mom too. Thanks a lot Torsten! – mayooran Oct 23 '18 at 9:27
  • You're welcome. Enjoy your time in Germany, in whatever part of the country. – TorstenS Oct 23 '18 at 10:12
  • @TorstenS, you are linking a page about spouses, not parents. As I read it, the rules for parents are much more restrictive. – o.m. Oct 23 '18 at 16:44
1

I am not a lawyer, and this is not intended as legal advice, but §36 AufenthG says

(2) Sonstigen Familienangehörigen eines Ausländers kann zum Familiennachzug eine Aufenthaltserlaubnis erteilt werden, wenn es zur Vermeidung einer außergewöhnlichen Härte erforderlich ist.

A residence permit may be granted to other family members (e.g. parents of a grown child) of a foreigner if that is necessary to avoid unusual hardship.

  • Someone who applies based on §36 would have to explain why it would be an unusual hardship for the parent to stay in her or his homeland.

  • Someone who applies to a normal Schengen visa would have to demonstrate ties to the homeland and reasons why one would return.

To me this looks like a problem. First one writes that the parent wants to visit briefly and that he or she will definitely return afterwards. Then one writes that the parent would face unusual hardship if the stays home. If there is enough time between those two statements, they might look credible. Circumstances change. A mother may become more infirm. If they come directly after each other, they cannot both be true.

  • The question was weather a visit of the mother to Germany would weaken the chance to get a permanent permit later. I cannot see how the fact that his mother once visited Germany would change her situation back home. Please note we are not talking about asylum / refugees here. In that case, you would be right that returning home and than arguing that it's hard to stay at home would not make sense. But immigration and asylum are two entirely separate areas of law. – TorstenS Oct 24 '18 at 17:00
  • @TorstenS, I'm not talking about asylum either, but family reunification for parents as a dependent which is different from spouses or children as dependents. – o.m. Oct 24 '18 at 18:09

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.