I hope somebody who really knows about Canadian eTa permit can answer my question.

I was a university student in Canada for one year (2015 - 2016) and I had a valid student permit (which expired on the 30th of December 2016). I really want to go to Canada to visit my friends and I have never been denied a Canadian visa nor did I get denied my student permit/visa the first time that I applied for it.

I applied for U.S visa when I was in Vancouver and they denied it (as usual, since I am a Mexican citizen). I never had any trouble with Canadian authorities, but I got my U.S visa denied in Canada.

I'd like to travel to Canada to visit my friends and since my student visa/permit expired, I have to apply for a eTa as Mexico is part of the visa-exempt countries. There's a question on the eTa which says the following: "Have you ever been refused a visa or permit, denied entry or ordered to leave Canada or any other country?"

I know that I have to answer "Yes" and explain why. There's also another question which asks if you have ever had any kind of Canadian permit/visa which I've had (my Canadian study permit/visa).

Does it have a big impact if you've been denied a U.S visa? and would it be positive if I've had a Canadian study permit/visa before?

*I don't have any criminal record or overstayed in Canada. I actually left the country on September the 12th 2016 and my student visa expired on December the 31st 2016.

I am scared that I might get my eTa denied because of the declined U.S visa, which was total misunderstanding. When I arrived to the U.S consulate in Vancouver, the Chinese-American visa officer (who was really rude and impolite) asked me where did I want to go and I said: "to Seattle for a few days" and then he asked if I had any family in the U.S and I said: "No" cause I don't have any family in the U.S. He then told me that my application had been refused and when I asked about the reason he told me that I had lied. It's really unfair that because of him, I don't know what to explain on the eTa application and I know that the U.S and Canada share records. I feel really frustrated that it may affect my application.

Could somebody please help me out and guide me a little?

closed as primarily opinion-based by JonathanReez Jul 6 '18 at 18:07

Many good questions generate some degree of opinion based on expert experience, but answers to this question will tend to be almost entirely based on opinions, rather than facts, references, or specific expertise. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 3
    I suspect that the US visa denial will have a modest negative effect on your application and that your history of complying with your previous visa will have a much more significant positive impact. But who knows, really? The best thing to do is to apply. – phoog Mar 1 '18 at 6:51
  • Your U.S Visa refusal was under which section? – Hanky Panky Mar 1 '18 at 7:17
  • I am not familiar with sections but I remember that the officer gave me a blue paper which DIDN'T say anything specifically like "I was banned from the country because I had "lied" or something like that, it only said: your application has been refused and a list of reasons for why it could've been denied but nothing specifically. I don't have the paper anymore but I remember that I didn't say anything bad or unusual. Just a few reasons, that my application had been refused and some Q&A related to denial on the back of it. He didn't stamp or write anything on my passport either, is that good? – Ivan Mar 1 '18 at 7:27
  • If it was just 214(b) it will have negligible impact but if it did say something about deception it might have a big impact but everything we say is guesswork. You won't find out until you apply – Hanky Panky Mar 1 '18 at 7:31
  • But if the paper didn't contain any specific information other than typical reasons and that my application had been denied, I guess it should be 214 (b), right? If it had been another one, it would've said something else. What do you think? – Ivan Mar 1 '18 at 7:40